I challenge you who are against the Water Compact to prove my conclusions are wrong!

by Dr. Ed Berry

A month or so ago, I tended to side with those who challenge the CSKT Water Compact. But a good scientist always looks for evidence that his theory is wrong.

Therefore, I took a few days and compared the written claims of Senator Verdell Jackson, Dr. Kate Vandemoer, and Attorney Richard Simms against the legal rebuttals by Attorney Helen Thigpen, Staff Attorney for the Montana Water Policy Committee, and Attorney Hertha Lund who represents the Montana Water Stewards, a private, non-partisan organization comprised of farmers and ranchers on the Flathead Indian Reservation, and their supporters.

As a “member of the jury” my conclusion is clear. The claims against the Compact do not stand up against their rebuttals. I put my reasons in the following 3 articles.

Yet after the Pachyderm meeting in Kalispell today, one well-known lady told me publicly in no uncertain terms that I “am wrong!”

OK, let this lady and anyone else who thinks I am wrong, please show me why in the comment sections of the 3 articles below.

Thanks and Merry Christmas,

Ed (49)

Simms’ claims against Water Compact fail

by Dr. Ed Berry

We have shown the claims against the Compact by Senator Verdell Jackson and Dr. Vandemoer are invalid.

In November 2014, Western Montana Water Rights (WMWR) published claims against the CSKT Water Compact by Attorney Richard Simms who is a New Mexico attorney not licensed to practice law in Montana.

Having Simms write claims is a clear admission by Compact opponents that they have produced no valid claim since they began their opposition in June 2012 because if they had even one valid claim, they would not need Simms.

Montana Attorney Hertha Lund countered Simms’ claims for her clients and made her rebuttal public. Here is a summary of Lund’s rebuttal to Simms. Attorneys should read Lund’s version.

[Continue reading] (134)

Dr. Kate’s claims against Water Compact fail

by Dr. Ed Berry

Dr. Kate Vandemoer (Dr. Kate) will present her case against Montana’s CSKT Water Compact to the Glacier Forum in Kalispell on Thursday, December 17. You may want to read this before you attend.

Dr. Kate Vandemoer has made a lot of waves since becoming a Water Compact consultant to the Compact opposition. She claims we should reject the CSKT Water Compact.

The fact is, Dr. Kate is wrong about almost every claim she has made. At the end of the day, she will go home to Arizona with Montana money in her purse primed to find others who will pay her to tell them what they want to hear, and the Montanans who believed her will be poorer.

Dr. Kate does not understand the Flathead Irrigation and Power Project (FIPP). [Continue reading] (125)

Senator’s claim against Water Compact fails

by Dr. Ed Berry

During the past week, I studied the arguments for and against the CSKT Water Compact. The conclusion is clear: the arguments opposing the Compact are legal vaporware.

Here, I rebut Senator Verdell Jackson’s recent articleHell Gate Treaty Forbids Off-Reservation Water Rights Contained in CSKT Water Compact.”

Later, I will rebut Arizona hydrologist Dr. Kate Vandemoer’s and New Mexico attorney Richard Simms’ claims against the Compact. [Continue reading] (433)

Chemtrail Delusions vs Scientific Method


by Dr. Ed Berry On the left, we have global warming believers. On the far right, we have chemtrail believers. It gets worse. Read on. At the request of some friends, I watched the 15-minute video by Jeff Rense and Dane Wigington titled “The … [Continue reading]

Why Roger Koopman’s TAB Scores Don’t Work

by Dr. Ed Berry Roger Koopman developed his TAB scores to help define a true Republican. While many Republicans suspect there is something wrong with TAB scores, no one so far has been able to identify the problem. Hey, all pioneers take … [Continue reading]

Radicals omit Ethics & Law in Tutvedt Attack


by Sandy Welch, 2012 Republican Candidate for Montana Office of Public Instruction On November 17, I explained why the claimed "censure" of Senator Bruce Tutvedt by the Flathead County Republican Central Committee (FCRCC) is an unsupported, … [Continue reading]

Radical Rs abandon Ethics in Personal Attacks


On November 10, Gina sent a public email accusing Republicans who support the CSKT Water Compact of accepting “bribe” money to attack other Republicans. But the so-called “bribe” money was a transparent public contribution and the so-called “attack” … [Continue reading]

True Voting Principle proves Koopman wrong

The True Voting Principle proves Roger Koopman, Chuck Baldwin, Stewart Rhodes, Oath Keepers, and John Birch Society are morally and logically wrong on how to vote. by Dr. Ed Berry Roger Koopman weighed in on my article “Chuck Baldwin is wrong about … [Continue reading]

Ryan Zinke’s America

Montana will elect Commander Ryan Zinke to Congress on November 4, 2014. Ryan Zinke will go on to become one of the greatest men America has ever elected to Congress. I am both humbled and proud to support Ryan Zinke for Congress. - Dr. Ed … [Continue reading]

Bill Whittle: The truth about Mitt Romney

Now read this Summary of Mitt Romney's Plan for America. I am one of the few who saved it and over 5000 people have read it. This summary establishes without a doubt that Mitt Romney would have been much better for America. … [Continue reading]

Summary of Mitt Romney’s Plan for America


I posted on September 28, 2012, but it' time to bring it to the top again to counter the rightwing extremist claim that there is no difference between Rs and Ds. Voters who rejected Mitt Romney should realize what they lost. When will they ever … [Continue reading]

The problem in Ferguson

by Pat Buchanan, Buchanan.org “It is ordained in the eternal constitution of things, that men of intemperate minds cannot be free. Their passions forge their fetters.” Edmund Burke’s insight returned to mind while watching cable news … [Continue reading]

Six ways Republicans will change Energy Policy


Marita Noon shows a giant difference between Republicans and Democrats, proving those who believe the Moron Mantra are, well, morons. - Ed by Marita Noon Six energy policy changes to watch for in a Republican-controlled Congress Now that … [Continue reading]

Preparing for 2015 Legislative Session

by Senator Jennifer Fielder, R-Montana State Senate District 7 Last week Montana legislators were called together at the State Capitol in Helena to begin preparations for the 2015 legislative session which will run pretty much full time from … [Continue reading]

Pete Seeger: Where Have All the Flowers Gone?

[Continue reading]

Veterans Day Message


MG Paul Vallely delivered this Veterans Day Message at Depot Park, Kalispell, Montana, at 11:00 am on 11/11/2014  in 13 F weather. by MG Paul Vallely, US Army (Ret), Chairman, Stand Up America On the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month of … [Continue reading]

Oath Keepers Chaplain wanted Montana Blue


by Dr. Ed Berry Look at the large red area where voters elected Republicans to US Congress. If Oath Keepers National Chaplain Pastor Chuck Baldwin and his followers had their way, the whole State of Montana would have been blue. … [Continue reading]

Message to Obama from a former Muslim

[Continue reading]

America and Montana choose the Greater Good


by Dr. Ed Berry Republicans picked up 9 seats in the US Senate (7 races competed and 2 in process) and more seats in the US House. Say “Good bye” to Harry Reid as Republicans take control the US Senate in 2015. This 2014 Republican sweep is a … [Continue reading]

Obama covered up murder of Shane Todd

Published on Oct 31, 2014 This show examines President Obama’s management of the cover-up of the murder of Shane Truman Todd, a young American engineer in Singapore who had been working on a contract involving the giant Chinese company … [Continue reading]

The Value of Positive Thinking


by Dr. Ed Berry In the past month, I showed how radicals, liberal and conservative, use negative false Mantras in their voting. I showed their negative Mantras are illogical and immoral, without taking a position for or against any religion, or for … [Continue reading]

Daines and Zinke are correct on Climate Change

by Dr. Ed Berry Jerry Elwood (DIL October 26) attacks Congressman Steve Daines on climate change. Elwood uses “ideological” eleven times and “belief” five times, showing his climate alarmism. Elwood, an ecologist, is outside his field of … [Continue reading]

A Vote for a Democrat is a Vote for Islam

Recommended by Alan West Download and print this handy leaflet that explains the three stages of jihad. … [Continue reading]

Climate Change is a religious cult


[Continue reading]

America: Imagine a World without Her


by Dr. Ed Berry The question is: “Is America worth saving?” Dinesh D'Souza's “America: Imagine a World without Her” explains why we must stop Obama and the Progressive Democrats from taking America down. "America: Imagine a World without … [Continue reading]

Roger Koopman puts conscience before party

I publish this contrary opinion at Roger Koopman's request. In my opinion, Roger's position is suicidal, illogical, and immoral. Read D'Souza's America or watch his DVD. Democrats are now the Progressive-Communist Party. The place to resolve … [Continue reading]

Why Democrat supporters are traitors

In 2012, Oath Keepers National Chaplain Pastor Chuck Baldwin wrote "the differences between Mitt Romney and Barack Obama are miniscule" and Oath Keepers leader Stewart Rhodes called Republicans Mitt Romney and Denny Rehberg "oath breakers". In 2014, … [Continue reading]

You are responsible for Obama’s re-election

by Marita Noon Shouldn’t be we fighting a war on terrorism not on fossil fuels? “You are responsible for President Obama’s re-election,” I told 150 folks from the oil and gas industry —most of whom were conservative Republicans. I spoke to them … [Continue reading]

Elect Zinke and Daines – our best hope for Montana

by MG Paul Vallely, US Army (Ret), Chairman, Stand Up America To my fellow Montanans: We truly stand in troubled times as our Republic is challenged from home and abroad.. As our way of life has been ‘fundamentally changed’ for the worse by the … [Continue reading]

Tea Party Libertarian Thinking

by Dr. Ed Berry ... Or why conservative Montana has two Democrat US Senators and a Democrat Governor. Ele added comment @8 on PolyMontana article Chuck Baldwin is wrong about Ryan Zinke: @Ed I spoke with Zinke earlier this year about the CSKT … [Continue reading]

Chuck Baldwin is wrong about Ryan Zinke

by Dr. Ed Berry, NewsWithViews (2000-word version), 2800-word version below Pastor Chuck Baldwin’s “Ryan Zinke: The Greater Evil” rejects accepted Christian theology, supports Alinsky-trained Obama and his plan for America, and tells you to vote … [Continue reading]

Is Multiculturalism good or bad for America?

by Michael Anthony Peroutka In 2008, during Obama’s first national campaign, Barack Obama is on record saying that America is not a Christian Nation. “Whatever we once were, we are no longer a Christian nation - at least not just,” Obama said. … [Continue reading]